Back

Table of content

Supply Chain Restructuring – The ‘Hidden Gold Mine’ 

Amidst today's focus on digital transformation and agile methodologies, Supply Chain Restructuring, the fundamental redesign of how goods and information flow, often gets overlooked. Yet, it remains a potent force for radical improvement. By strategically reconfiguring the network, processes, and the crucial Order Entry Point, businesses can unlock significant gains. A well-executed restructuring can dramatically enhance efficiency by streamlining operations and reducing waste or dramatically improving responsiveness by bringing production and fulfillment closer to the customer. This foundational approach, when thoughtfully applied, can yield transformative and lasting advantages in a dynamic marketplace.  

What is Supply Chain Restructuring? 

Supply Chain Restructuring involves fundamentally redesigning a company's supply chain to improve its performance and resilience. It goes beyond incremental improvements and aims for significant strategic and operational shifts. Think of it as an organization taking a hard look at how materials, information, and finances flow and then rebuilding that flow in a smarter way.    

Efficiency and Responsiveness are two primary, yet often competing, objectives in supply chain restructuring. Efficiency centers on optimizing resource utilization to minimize costs. This involves streamlining processes, reducing waste, optimizing inventory levels, and maximizing output with minimal input. The focus is on cost leadership through economies of scale and operational excellence. 

Responsiveness, conversely, emphasizes the supply chain's agility and ability to adapt swiftly to changes in demand, market dynamics, or disruptions. A responsive supply chain prioritizes speed, flexibility, and customer satisfaction, even if it entails slightly higher operational costs. This involves shorter lead times, flexible production, and the capacity to quickly adjust to unforeseen circumstances. 

Restructuring initiatives often seek to strike a balance between these two objectives. While efficiency drives down costs, responsiveness ensures the supply chain can meet evolving customer needs and navigate uncertainty, ultimately contributing to long-term competitiveness. The optimal balance depends on factors such as industry characteristics, product nature, and customer expectations. 

What do we gain when ‘Efficiency’ is our primary objective? 

Supply chain restructuring drives efficiency in several key ways: 

  • Reduced Costs: By optimizing network design, consolidating warehouses, streamlining transportation, and improving sourcing strategies, companies can significantly lower operational expenses.    
  • Improved Speed and Agility: Restructuring can shorten lead times, enhance responsiveness to demand changes, and enable quicker adaptation to disruptions. This is achieved through better information flow, optimized processes, and potentially nearshoring or reshoring production. 
  • Enhanced Resilience: A well-restructured supply chain is more robust and better equipped to handle unexpected events like natural disasters, geopolitical instability, or supplier failures through diversification, redundancy, and flexible sourcing options. 
  • Increased Visibility: Implementing advanced technologies and redesigning information flows during restructuring provides better transparency across the entire supply chain, allowing for proactive decision-making and issue resolution.    
  • Better Asset Utilization: Optimizing inventory levels, production capacity, and logistics infrastructure leads to more efficient use of capital and resources.    

Understanding the three dimensions of Supply Chain Restructuring: 

three dimensions of Supply Chain Restructuring

Crucial decisions could be made with the help of Supply Chain Restructuring for developing cost reduction initiatives, especially when businesses are striving hard to bring more efficiency into the way they operate. These decisions are formed with the help of three dimensions of Supply Chain Restructuring which are: 

Value Addition Curve 

The Value Addition Curve is a graphical representation that illustrates how value is added to a product or service as it moves through the different stages of the supply chain. The horizontal axis typically represents the various stages or activities in the supply chain (e.g., raw material sourcing, manufacturing, assembly, distribution, retail), while the vertical axis represents the value added at each stage (often measured in terms of cost, price, or utility). 

The curve generally slopes upwards, indicating that each stage of the supply chain contributes to the final value of the product or service. The steepness of the slope at different stages reflects the magnitude of value addition at those points. For example, manufacturing or branding might represent steeper inclines due to significant transformation or differentiation. 

Point of Differentiation 

The Point of Differentiation (POD) in supply chain restructuring is the stage where a product or service becomes unique to gain a competitive edge. Strategically positioning the POD is vital for responsiveness, cost efficiency, and managing risk. 

Moving the POD downstream (postponement) delays customization, allowing for greater flexibility and reduced inventory of finished goods. Modular design supports later differentiation using standardized components. Process restructuring can optimize where differentiation occurs. 

The chosen POD impacts how a company meets customer needs, manages costs, and adapts to market changes. Careful consideration of the POD is essential during supply chain restructuring to enhance competitiveness and efficiency. 

Order Entry Point  

In supply chain restructuring, the Order Entry Point (OEP), or Customer Order Decoupling Point, is the strategic point where a generic product flow transitions to fulfilling specific customer orders. Upstream of the OEP, activities are forecast-driven (push); downstream, they are order-driven (pull). 

Restructuring often involves strategically relocating the OEP to achieve new objectives. Moving it downstream (closer to the customer) increases responsiveness and customization (e.g., postponement), but can raise costs and complexity in upstream. Moving it upstream (further from the customer) enhances efficiency and standardization (e.g., make-to-stock), potentially sacrificing flexibility and lead times. 

The optimal OEP depends on factors like product characteristics, market needs, cost considerations, and desired competitive advantages. Restructuring might shift the OEP to optimize inventory levels, manage complexity, and improve overall supply chain performance by aligning production and distribution more effectively with actual customer demand. This critical decision impacts on the entire supply chain design and its ability to deliver value.  

How to visualize and analyze a Value Addition Curve? 

You must have observed that Value Addition Curve, especially in the context of Supply Chain Restructuring, which includes both, the Point of Differentiation and the Order Entry Point, although they are represented in different ways and serve distinct purposes within the analysis. 

Here's how: 

  • Point of Differentiation in Value Addition Curve: As discussed earlier, the primary function of a Value Addition Curve (or Strategy Canvas) is to visually highlight how different offerings compare across various competitive factors. These factors are chosen based on what customers value. By analyzing the shape and relative positions of the curves, you can clearly identify where a particular offering differentiates itself from competitors by providing more (or sometimes less, strategically) value on specific factors. In supply chain restructuring, you might use this to see how changes in the supply chain (e.g., postponement, different sourcing) impact the differentiation of the final product or service.    
  • Order Entry Point in Value Addition Curve: In the context of supply chain restructuring, the Order Entry Point signifies how far into the supply chain a customer's order penetrates before customization or final configuration occurs. While the standard Value Addition Curve might not have "Order Entry Point" as a specific axis or factor, its implications can be visualized and analyzed in relation to the curve. 

What are the steps to create a Value Addition Curve for graphical representation? 

To effectively use the three dimensions of Supply Chain Restructuring, we need to create a Value Addition Curve that accommodates our Point of Differentiation and Order Entry Point. Here’s how we can create a visualization which graphically represents a Value Addition Curve:   

  1. Identify the Supply Chain Stages: Define the key stages involved in bringing your product or service to the end customer. Be specific and sequential. Examples include: 
    • Raw Material Extraction/Sourcing 
    • Component Manufacturing 
    • Assembly 
    • Packaging 
    • Distribution to Wholesalers 
    • Distribution to Retailers 
    • Retail Sales 
    • Post-Sales Service 
  1. Determine the Value Added at Each Stage: Quantify the value added at each stage. This can be done by calculating the increase in cost or price as the product moves through each stage. For instance: 
    • Raw Material Sourcing: Cost of raw materials. 
    • Component Manufacturing: Cost of raw materials + manufacturing costs (labor, overhead, etc.). The value added is the manufacturing costs. 
    • Assembly: Cost of components + assembly costs. The value added is the assembly costs. 
    • Packaging: Cost of assembled product + packaging costs. The value added is the packaging costs. 
    • Distribution (Wholesale): Cost of packaged product + distribution costs + wholesaler's margin. The value added is the distribution costs + wholesaler's margin. 
    • Distribution (Retail): Cost from wholesaler + retailer's margin. The value added is the retailer's margin. 
    • Retail Sales: Final selling price. The total value added is the difference between the final selling price and the initial raw material cost. 

Alternatively, you can focus on the utility added at each stage from the customer's perspective. This is more qualitative but can provide insights into brand value, convenience, and service. 

  1. Plot the Data Points: Create a graph with the supply chain stages (Time) on the horizontal (x) axis and the cumulative value (Cost) on the vertical (y) axis. For each stage, plot a point corresponding to the cumulative value up to that stage. 
  1. Connect the Points: Draw a line connecting the plotted points to create the value addition curve. 
  1. Analyze the Curve: Observe the shape and slope of the curve. Identify stages where significant value is added and stages where the value addition is relatively small. This analysis can help identify areas for potential optimization or strategic focus. 

Summary 

Supply Chain Restructuring could be a hidden gold mine, especially for organizations wanting to radically reduce the cost while creating a balance between efficiency and responsiveness. Any business that indulges in manufacturing / trading goods, will always have a set of value-added activities which are inter-connected to enable the flow of goods from upstream to downstream (Value Chain). These value chain activities easily contribute to a significant amount of total costs. Supply Chain Restructuring should be used to remove the redundancy from such activities which will eventually alter the Value Addition Curve, giving us a more efficient supply chain. 


Lumel enables organizations to uncover hidden efficiencies through smart Supply Chain Restructuring—helping them reshape their value chains, strike the right balance between efficiency and responsiveness, and thrive in a dynamic market landscape. The firm was recognized as the best new vendor for EPM in 2024.  

To follow our experts and receive thought leadership insights on data & analytics, register for one of our webinars.  To learn how Lumel Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) supports new product introductions, reach out to us today. 

Request a demo

Learn how Lumel helps enterprises deliver real-time integrated reporting and planning applications

Get Lumel Brochure

Enhance your BI, analytics and xP&A use cases with our no-code Data App suite for Power BI.
Download now
Lumel
Lumel empowers enterprises to look forward and think ahead with an innovative suite of products for real-time integrated planning, reporting, and analytics. Designed for business users, Lumel delivers cutting-edge, no-code, self-service user experiences to leverage your modern data platform investments, reduce TCO, and retire legacy solutions.

Headquarters

5920 Windhaven Pkwy
Plano TX 75093
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram